construction lawHZLegalThe Legal Implications of BIM Technology in Construction Contracts

“Navigating the legal landscape of BIM technology in construction contracts.”

Introduction

BIM technology, or Building Information Modeling, has revolutionized the construction industry by providing a digital representation of a building’s physical and functional characteristics. As this technology becomes more prevalent in construction projects, it is important to consider the legal implications it may have on construction contracts. This article will explore some of the key legal considerations that arise when incorporating BIM technology into construction contracts.

Benefits of Implementing BIM Technology in Construction Contracts

Building Information Modeling (BIM) technology has revolutionized the construction industry by providing a digital representation of a building’s physical and functional characteristics. This technology allows architects, engineers, and contractors to collaborate more effectively, resulting in improved project outcomes. One of the key benefits of implementing BIM technology in construction contracts is the ability to reduce errors and conflicts during the design and construction phases.

By creating a 3D model of the building, stakeholders can visualize the project before it is built, allowing them to identify potential issues early on. This early detection of clashes and conflicts can help prevent costly delays and rework, ultimately saving time and money. Additionally, BIM technology enables real-time collaboration and communication among project team members, leading to more efficient decision-making and problem-solving.

Another advantage of using BIM technology in construction contracts is the ability to improve project coordination and sequencing. With a detailed 3D model of the building, contractors can better plan and schedule construction activities, ensuring that work is completed in the most efficient and cost-effective manner. This level of coordination can help reduce construction waste and improve overall project sustainability.

Furthermore, BIM technology can enhance the accuracy and quality of construction documentation. By linking the 3D model to project specifications and other relevant information, stakeholders can ensure that all project requirements are met. This integrated approach to documentation can help minimize disputes and claims during the construction process, ultimately leading to smoother project delivery.

In addition to improving project outcomes, implementing BIM technology in construction contracts can also have legal implications. As BIM technology becomes more prevalent in the industry, it is important for stakeholders to understand the potential legal risks and liabilities associated with its use. One of the key legal implications of BIM technology is the need to clearly define each party’s responsibilities and obligations in the contract.

When incorporating BIM technology into a construction contract, it is essential to address issues such as intellectual property rights, liability for errors and omissions, and data ownership. For example, who owns the BIM model and who is responsible for maintaining and updating it throughout the project? These questions must be addressed in the contract to avoid disputes and ensure that all parties are clear on their rights and obligations.

Another legal implication of BIM technology in construction contracts is the potential for increased liability for design professionals. As BIM technology allows for more detailed and accurate project documentation, design professionals may be held to a higher standard of care in their work. This increased level of scrutiny can lead to greater exposure to claims of professional negligence or breach of contract.

In conclusion, the benefits of implementing BIM technology in construction contracts are clear. From reducing errors and conflicts to improving project coordination and documentation, BIM technology can help stakeholders achieve better project outcomes. However, it is important for stakeholders to be aware of the legal implications of using BIM technology and to address these issues in the contract. By carefully defining each party’s responsibilities and obligations, stakeholders can mitigate legal risks and ensure a successful project delivery.

Risks and Challenges Associated with BIM Technology in Construction Contracts

Building Information Modeling (BIM) technology has revolutionized the construction industry by providing a digital representation of a building’s physical and functional characteristics. While BIM offers numerous benefits such as improved collaboration, reduced errors, and enhanced project visualization, it also presents a unique set of risks and challenges when it comes to construction contracts.

One of the key risks associated with BIM technology in construction contracts is the potential for disputes over intellectual property rights. BIM models contain a wealth of information, including design details, specifications, and other proprietary data. As such, there is a risk that one party may use the BIM model without proper authorization, leading to disputes over ownership and usage rights.

To mitigate this risk, construction contracts should clearly outline the ownership and usage rights of the BIM model. Parties should specify who owns the intellectual property rights to the BIM model, how it can be used, and whether it can be shared with third parties. By clearly defining these terms in the contract, parties can avoid potential disputes over intellectual property rights.

Another challenge associated with BIM technology in construction contracts is the potential for errors and omissions in the BIM model. BIM models are complex and detailed, and errors in the model can have significant implications for the construction project. For example, if a design error is not caught in the BIM model, it could lead to costly rework and delays during construction.

To address this challenge, construction contracts should include provisions for quality control and assurance of the BIM model. Parties should establish procedures for reviewing and verifying the accuracy of the BIM model, as well as mechanisms for addressing errors and omissions in a timely manner. By incorporating these provisions into the contract, parties can minimize the risk of errors in the BIM model and ensure the successful completion of the construction project.

In addition to intellectual property rights and errors in the BIM model, another risk associated with BIM technology in construction contracts is the potential for data security breaches. BIM models contain sensitive information, and if this data is compromised, it could have serious consequences for the construction project and the parties involved.

To address this risk, construction contracts should include provisions for data security and confidentiality. Parties should establish protocols for protecting the BIM model from unauthorized access, disclosure, or modification. Additionally, parties should outline procedures for responding to data security breaches, including notifying affected parties and taking appropriate remedial action. By incorporating these provisions into the contract, parties can safeguard the security and confidentiality of the BIM model and mitigate the risk of data breaches.

In conclusion, while BIM technology offers numerous benefits for the construction industry, it also presents a unique set of risks and challenges when it comes to construction contracts. By addressing issues such as intellectual property rights, errors in the BIM model, and data security breaches in the contract, parties can effectively manage these risks and ensure the successful implementation of BIM technology in construction projects.

Building Information Modeling (BIM) technology has revolutionized the construction industry by providing a digital representation of a building’s physical and functional characteristics. This technology allows for better collaboration among project stakeholders, improved decision-making, and increased efficiency in the construction process. However, the adoption of BIM technology in construction contracts raises several legal implications that must be carefully considered.

One of the key legal issues surrounding BIM technology in construction contracts is the allocation of risk. BIM technology can help identify potential design clashes and construction conflicts early in the project, reducing the likelihood of costly disputes. However, if errors or omissions occur in the BIM model, it can be challenging to determine who is responsible for the resulting issues. Contractors may argue that they relied on the accuracy of the BIM model provided by the owner or designer, while owners and designers may claim that the contractor failed to properly interpret the model. As a result, construction contracts must clearly define each party’s responsibilities regarding the use of BIM technology and establish mechanisms for resolving disputes that may arise.

Another legal consideration in construction contracts involving BIM technology is intellectual property rights. BIM models contain a wealth of information, including architectural designs, engineering data, and construction specifications. Owners, designers, and contractors must agree on how this information will be shared, used, and protected throughout the project. Issues such as ownership of the BIM model, licensing rights, and confidentiality agreements must be addressed in the contract to prevent unauthorized use or disclosure of sensitive information.

Furthermore, the use of BIM technology in construction contracts raises concerns about data security and privacy. BIM models often contain sensitive information that could be vulnerable to cyberattacks or data breaches. Owners, designers, and contractors must implement appropriate security measures to protect the integrity and confidentiality of the BIM data. Additionally, construction contracts should include provisions addressing data ownership, access controls, and data retention policies to mitigate the risk of unauthorized access or misuse of BIM information.

In addition to risk allocation, intellectual property rights, and data security, construction contracts involving BIM technology must also address liability issues. BIM models are dynamic and constantly evolving throughout the project lifecycle. Changes made to the model can impact the design, construction, and operation of the building. If errors or discrepancies in the BIM model lead to delays, cost overruns, or defects in the finished project, parties may seek to hold each other liable for the resulting damages. Construction contracts should include provisions outlining the standard of care expected from each party when using BIM technology and establish procedures for addressing errors, changes, and discrepancies in the model.

In conclusion, the adoption of BIM technology in construction contracts offers numerous benefits, but also presents several legal challenges that must be carefully addressed. By considering issues such as risk allocation, intellectual property rights, data security, and liability, parties can mitigate the legal risks associated with BIM technology and ensure successful project delivery. Construction contracts should be drafted with precision and clarity to reflect the unique legal implications of using BIM technology in the construction industry. Failure to address these issues adequately could result in costly disputes, delays, and legal liabilities for all parties involved.

Intellectual Property Rights in BIM Technology

Building Information Modeling (BIM) technology has revolutionized the construction industry by providing a digital representation of a building’s physical and functional characteristics. This technology allows architects, engineers, and contractors to collaborate more efficiently, resulting in improved project outcomes. However, the use of BIM technology in construction contracts raises important legal implications, particularly in the realm of intellectual property rights.

One of the key issues surrounding BIM technology is the ownership of the digital models created during the design and construction process. In traditional construction contracts, ownership of the project documents typically rests with the architect or engineer who created them. However, in the case of BIM technology, multiple parties may contribute to the creation of the digital model, raising questions about who owns the intellectual property rights to the model.

To address this issue, construction contracts should clearly define the ownership of the BIM model and any associated intellectual property rights. Parties should consider whether the ownership of the model should be shared among all project participants or if it should be assigned to a specific party. Additionally, contracts should specify how the model can be used, modified, and shared by the parties involved in the project.

Another important consideration in BIM technology is the protection of intellectual property rights. Digital models created using BIM technology may contain valuable proprietary information, such as design concepts, construction methods, and material specifications. Parties must take steps to protect this information from unauthorized use or disclosure.

Construction contracts should include provisions that address the confidentiality and security of BIM models. Parties should agree on how the models will be stored, accessed, and shared to prevent unauthorized access or use. Additionally, contracts should outline the procedures for handling confidential information and the consequences of breaching confidentiality obligations.

In addition to ownership and confidentiality issues, parties must also consider the licensing of BIM technology in construction contracts. BIM software is typically licensed to users under specific terms and conditions, which may restrict how the software can be used and shared. Parties must ensure that they have the necessary licenses to use BIM technology and that they comply with the terms of the license agreements.

Construction contracts should include provisions that address the licensing of BIM software and any restrictions on its use. Parties should also consider how the costs of licensing and maintaining the software will be allocated among project participants. By addressing these issues upfront, parties can avoid disputes over the use and ownership of BIM technology during the course of the project.

In conclusion, the use of BIM technology in construction contracts raises important legal implications, particularly in the realm of intellectual property rights. Parties must carefully consider issues such as ownership, confidentiality, and licensing when incorporating BIM technology into their projects. By addressing these issues in construction contracts, parties can protect their intellectual property rights and ensure the successful implementation of BIM technology in construction projects.

Liability Issues in BIM Technology Implementation

The Legal Implications of BIM Technology in Construction Contracts
Building Information Modeling (BIM) technology has revolutionized the construction industry by providing a digital representation of a building’s physical and functional characteristics. While BIM offers numerous benefits such as improved collaboration, reduced errors, and enhanced project visualization, its implementation also raises important legal implications, particularly in the realm of liability issues.

One of the key liability issues in BIM technology implementation is the allocation of responsibility among project participants. In traditional construction contracts, the roles and responsibilities of each party are clearly defined. However, in BIM projects, the lines of responsibility can become blurred as multiple stakeholders contribute to the model. This can lead to disputes over who is ultimately responsible for errors or omissions in the BIM model.

To address this issue, construction contracts must clearly outline the roles and responsibilities of each party in relation to the BIM model. This includes specifying who is responsible for creating, updating, and maintaining the model, as well as establishing protocols for sharing information and resolving conflicts. By clearly defining these roles and responsibilities, construction contracts can help mitigate the risk of liability issues arising from BIM technology implementation.

Another liability issue in BIM technology implementation is the potential for errors or omissions in the model to result in costly construction defects. Unlike traditional 2D drawings, BIM models provide a comprehensive view of the building’s design, allowing for greater accuracy and coordination. However, if errors or omissions are not detected and corrected early on, they can lead to construction delays, cost overruns, and disputes over liability.

To address this risk, construction contracts should include provisions for quality control and assurance throughout the BIM process. This may involve regular reviews of the model by all project participants, as well as the implementation of protocols for identifying and resolving errors or omissions. By establishing clear procedures for quality control and assurance, construction contracts can help minimize the risk of errors in the BIM model leading to costly construction defects.

In addition to errors and omissions, another liability issue in BIM technology implementation is the potential for intellectual property disputes. BIM models contain a wealth of information, including design elements, specifications, and proprietary data. If this information is misused or misappropriated, it can lead to legal disputes over intellectual property rights.

To address this risk, construction contracts should include provisions for protecting intellectual property rights in the BIM model. This may involve specifying who owns the rights to the model and its components, as well as establishing protocols for sharing and using the information contained in the model. By clearly defining intellectual property rights in the BIM model, construction contracts can help prevent disputes over ownership and misuse of proprietary information.

In conclusion, the implementation of BIM technology in construction projects raises important legal implications, particularly in relation to liability issues. By addressing key concerns such as the allocation of responsibility, quality control and assurance, and intellectual property rights in construction contracts, project participants can help mitigate the risk of liability issues arising from BIM technology implementation. Ultimately, clear and comprehensive contracts are essential for ensuring the successful and legally sound use of BIM technology in construction projects.

Contractual Considerations for BIM Technology in Construction Projects

Building Information Modeling (BIM) technology has revolutionized the construction industry by providing a digital representation of a building’s physical and functional characteristics. This technology allows for better collaboration, coordination, and communication among project stakeholders, resulting in improved project outcomes. However, the adoption of BIM technology in construction projects raises several legal implications that must be carefully considered in construction contracts.

One of the key legal considerations when incorporating BIM technology into construction contracts is the allocation of risk. BIM technology can help identify potential design clashes and construction conflicts early in the project, reducing the likelihood of costly disputes. However, if errors or omissions occur in the BIM model, it can be challenging to determine who is responsible for the resulting issues. Therefore, construction contracts must clearly define the parties’ responsibilities regarding the creation, use, and maintenance of the BIM model to avoid disputes over liability.

Another important legal consideration is intellectual property rights. BIM technology involves the creation of digital models that may contain valuable intellectual property, such as design drawings, specifications, and other proprietary information. Construction contracts should address ownership and licensing rights to the BIM model to ensure that all parties have the necessary rights to use and modify the model throughout the project and beyond.

Furthermore, data security and confidentiality are critical legal considerations when using BIM technology in construction projects. BIM models may contain sensitive information that must be protected from unauthorized access or disclosure. Construction contracts should include provisions addressing data security measures, confidentiality obligations, and the handling of sensitive information to safeguard against data breaches and protect the parties’ interests.

In addition to these legal considerations, construction contracts must also address the use of BIM technology in project delivery and performance. BIM technology can streamline project management, improve coordination among project stakeholders, and enhance decision-making processes. However, the parties must agree on the standards, protocols, and procedures for using BIM technology to ensure that the project is completed successfully and in compliance with contractual requirements.

Moreover, construction contracts should address the integration of BIM technology with other project delivery methods, such as design-build or integrated project delivery. The parties must coordinate their efforts and responsibilities to ensure that the BIM model is effectively utilized throughout the project and that all parties benefit from the advantages of using BIM technology.

In conclusion, the adoption of BIM technology in construction projects offers numerous benefits, but it also raises several legal implications that must be carefully considered in construction contracts. By addressing issues such as risk allocation, intellectual property rights, data security, project delivery, and integration with other project delivery methods, construction contracts can help mitigate potential legal risks and ensure the successful implementation of BIM technology in construction projects. It is essential for project stakeholders to work together to develop comprehensive and well-defined contractual provisions that address the legal implications of using BIM technology and promote collaboration, transparency, and accountability throughout the project lifecycle.

Building Information Modeling (BIM) technology has revolutionized the construction industry by providing a digital representation of a building’s physical and functional characteristics. While BIM offers numerous benefits such as improved collaboration, reduced errors, and increased efficiency, it also raises unique legal challenges that must be addressed in construction contracts. One of the key areas where legal implications of BIM technology come into play is in dispute resolution mechanisms for BIM-related disputes.

When disputes arise in construction projects involving BIM technology, parties must carefully consider the appropriate dispute resolution mechanism to resolve their differences. Traditional methods of dispute resolution, such as litigation and arbitration, may not be well-suited to address the complex technical issues that often arise in BIM-related disputes. As a result, parties may need to consider alternative dispute resolution mechanisms that are better equipped to handle these types of disputes.

One such alternative dispute resolution mechanism is mediation. Mediation is a voluntary process in which a neutral third party, known as a mediator, helps parties reach a mutually acceptable resolution to their dispute. In the context of BIM-related disputes, mediation can be particularly effective because it allows parties to work together to find creative solutions to their problems without the need for formal legal proceedings. This can be especially beneficial in cases where technical issues related to BIM technology are at the heart of the dispute.

Another alternative dispute resolution mechanism that may be suitable for BIM-related disputes is expert determination. Expert determination involves appointing a neutral expert to resolve a specific technical issue in dispute between the parties. In the context of BIM technology, expert determination can be a valuable tool for resolving disputes over issues such as model accuracy, data ownership, or the interpretation of BIM standards. By relying on the expertise of a neutral third party, parties can avoid the time and expense of traditional legal proceedings while still obtaining a fair and impartial resolution to their dispute.

Collaborative contracting is another approach that can be used to address BIM-related disputes. Collaborative contracting involves parties working together in a spirit of cooperation and mutual respect to achieve common goals. In the context of BIM technology, collaborative contracting can help parties avoid disputes by fostering open communication, sharing information, and working together to address issues as they arise. By promoting a culture of collaboration and teamwork, parties can reduce the likelihood of disputes arising in the first place and can more effectively resolve any disputes that do occur.

In conclusion, the legal implications of BIM technology in construction contracts require careful consideration of the appropriate dispute resolution mechanisms to address BIM-related disputes. Parties should be aware of the unique technical issues that can arise in BIM-related disputes and should consider alternative dispute resolution mechanisms such as mediation, expert determination, and collaborative contracting to effectively resolve these disputes. By choosing the right dispute resolution mechanism, parties can minimize the time, cost, and complexity of resolving BIM-related disputes and can ensure that their construction projects are completed successfully and efficiently.

Insurance Coverage for BIM Technology Risks

Building Information Modeling (BIM) technology has revolutionized the construction industry by providing a digital representation of a building’s physical and functional characteristics. While BIM offers numerous benefits such as improved collaboration, reduced errors, and increased efficiency, it also presents unique legal challenges that must be addressed in construction contracts. One of the key areas where legal implications arise is in insurance coverage for BIM technology risks.

Insurance coverage for BIM technology risks is a complex issue that requires careful consideration by all parties involved in a construction project. Traditional insurance policies may not adequately cover the risks associated with BIM technology, which can include data breaches, design errors, and software malfunctions. As a result, it is essential for contractors, designers, and owners to carefully review their insurance policies and consider additional coverage options to protect against these risks.

One of the main challenges in obtaining insurance coverage for BIM technology risks is the lack of standardized insurance products specifically tailored to address these risks. Many insurance policies do not explicitly address BIM technology, leaving parties vulnerable to potential gaps in coverage. To mitigate this risk, parties should work with their insurance brokers to negotiate endorsements or riders that specifically address BIM technology risks.

In addition to negotiating specialized insurance coverage, parties should also consider incorporating indemnification provisions into their contracts to allocate risk for BIM technology-related issues. Indemnification provisions can help protect parties from liability arising from BIM technology risks by requiring one party to compensate the other for any losses or damages resulting from the use of BIM technology. These provisions should be carefully drafted to clearly define the scope of indemnification and allocate responsibility for specific types of risks.

Another important consideration in insurance coverage for BIM technology risks is the potential impact on professional liability insurance. Design professionals such as architects and engineers may face increased exposure to liability claims related to BIM technology, as errors or omissions in the digital model can have significant consequences during construction. Design professionals should review their professional liability insurance policies to ensure that they provide adequate coverage for BIM technology risks and consider obtaining additional coverage if necessary.

Overall, insurance coverage for BIM technology risks is a critical aspect of managing the legal implications of using BIM technology in construction contracts. Parties should carefully review their insurance policies, negotiate specialized coverage where necessary, and incorporate indemnification provisions into their contracts to protect against potential risks. By taking these steps, parties can help mitigate the legal challenges associated with BIM technology and ensure that they are adequately protected in the event of a claim.

Compliance with Building Regulations and Standards using BIM Technology

Building Information Modeling (BIM) technology has revolutionized the construction industry by providing a digital representation of a building’s physical and functional characteristics. This technology allows for the creation of 3D models that can be used for design, construction, and maintenance of buildings. However, with the adoption of BIM technology comes a host of legal implications that must be considered, particularly in the realm of construction contracts.

One of the key areas where BIM technology has a significant impact on construction contracts is in ensuring compliance with building regulations and standards. BIM technology allows for the creation of detailed 3D models that can be used to analyze and simulate various aspects of a building’s design, such as structural integrity, energy efficiency, and fire safety. By using BIM technology, construction professionals can ensure that their designs meet all relevant building codes and regulations.

In the context of construction contracts, compliance with building regulations and standards using BIM technology can help to mitigate the risk of costly delays and disputes. By using BIM technology to create accurate and detailed models of a building’s design, contractors can identify potential issues early in the construction process and make any necessary adjustments to ensure compliance with building regulations. This can help to prevent costly rework and delays that can arise from non-compliance with building codes.

Furthermore, BIM technology can also be used to track and document compliance with building regulations throughout the construction process. By creating a digital record of the design and construction process, contractors can provide evidence of compliance with building codes and regulations in the event of a dispute or legal challenge. This can help to protect contractors from liability and ensure that they are able to fulfill their contractual obligations.

In addition to ensuring compliance with building regulations and standards, BIM technology can also be used to improve communication and collaboration among project stakeholders. By creating a centralized digital model of a building’s design, contractors, architects, engineers, and other stakeholders can work together more effectively to identify and resolve potential issues. This can help to streamline the construction process and reduce the risk of disputes arising from miscommunication or misunderstandings.

Overall, the use of BIM technology in construction contracts can have a significant impact on ensuring compliance with building regulations and standards. By creating detailed 3D models of a building’s design, contractors can identify and address potential compliance issues early in the construction process, reducing the risk of costly delays and disputes. Additionally, BIM technology can help to improve communication and collaboration among project stakeholders, further enhancing the efficiency and effectiveness of the construction process.

In conclusion, the legal implications of BIM technology in construction contracts are vast and complex. However, by using BIM technology to ensure compliance with building regulations and standards, contractors can mitigate risk, improve communication, and ultimately deliver successful construction projects. As the construction industry continues to embrace BIM technology, it is essential for contractors to understand and address the legal implications of this technology in their contracts to ensure successful project outcomes.

Building Information Modeling (BIM) technology has revolutionized the construction industry by providing a digital representation of a building’s physical and functional characteristics. This technology allows architects, engineers, and contractors to collaborate more effectively, resulting in improved project outcomes. However, the adoption of BIM technology has also raised several legal implications that must be considered in construction contracts.

One of the key legal implications of BIM technology in construction contracts is the issue of liability. With the use of BIM technology, there is a greater potential for errors and omissions in the design and construction process. This raises questions about who is responsible for these errors and how liability should be allocated among the various parties involved in the project. Construction contracts must clearly define the roles and responsibilities of each party and establish mechanisms for resolving disputes related to liability.

Another legal implication of BIM technology in construction contracts is the issue of intellectual property rights. BIM models contain a wealth of information, including design drawings, specifications, and other proprietary data. It is essential for construction contracts to address ownership and licensing rights related to BIM models to prevent disputes over the use and distribution of this valuable information. Parties must also consider how changes to the BIM model will be managed and documented throughout the project.

Furthermore, the use of BIM technology in construction contracts raises concerns about data security and privacy. BIM models contain sensitive information that must be protected from unauthorized access or disclosure. Construction contracts should include provisions for safeguarding BIM data and ensuring compliance with data protection regulations. Parties must also consider how data breaches will be addressed and how liability for any resulting damages will be allocated.

In addition to these legal implications, the use of BIM technology in construction contracts also raises questions about standard contract terms and industry practices. Traditional construction contracts may not adequately address the unique challenges and opportunities presented by BIM technology. Parties must carefully review and revise contract terms to ensure that they are compatible with the use of BIM technology and reflect best practices in the industry.

Overall, the legal implications of BIM technology in construction contracts are complex and multifaceted. Parties must carefully consider these implications when drafting and negotiating construction contracts to avoid disputes and ensure successful project outcomes. By addressing issues such as liability, intellectual property rights, data security, and contract terms, parties can effectively navigate the legal challenges associated with the use of BIM technology in construction projects.

In conclusion, BIM technology has the potential to transform the construction industry by improving collaboration, efficiency, and project outcomes. However, the adoption of BIM technology also raises several legal implications that must be carefully considered in construction contracts. By addressing issues such as liability, intellectual property rights, data security, and contract terms, parties can effectively manage the legal challenges associated with the use of BIM technology and ensure successful project delivery.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the legal implications of BIM technology in construction contracts are significant and complex. It is important for all parties involved in a construction project to carefully consider and address these implications in their contracts to ensure clarity, accountability, and risk management. Failure to do so could result in disputes, delays, and potential legal issues down the line.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *